Analysis-Rocket startups face adapt-or-die moment amid investment drought
FILE PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: Relativity Space’s 3D-printed rocket Terran 1 sits is rolled out to the launch pad at the Cape Canaveral Air Force Station in this December 7, 2022 photograph released ahead of its scheduled launch in Cape Canaveral, Florida, March
By Joey Roulette
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Demand for sending satellites into space remains strong, but U.S. rocket startups are taking drastic measures to survive a tight funding environment where fears have been exacerbated by the bankruptcy of Virgin Orbit.
The industry faces an interesting dichotomy. Demand has surged from launching a few satellites on small rockets to launching swarms of satellites at once using bigger rockets, even as investors shy away from the sector in search of safer bets.
Venture investment in space startups has dropped 50% year-over-year in 2022 to $21.9 billion, according to VC firm Space Capital.
As the cost of capital rises with the Federal Reserve’s interest rate hikes, investors are less incentivized to fund capital intensive projects that do not have a clear revenue stream or path to profitability, leaving many space startups scrambling for funds.
“I’ve never raised capital in a harder market than the one we’re in right now,” Firefly Aerospace CEO Bill Weber said. “The I word and the R word – recession and inflation – make the investment market conservative and a little more cautious.”
The failure of billionaire Richard Branson’s Virgin Orbit, which filed for bankruptcy this month, has only ratcheted up pressure on rivals trying to keep up with Elon Musk’s SpaceX, Rocket Lab and the Boeing-Lockheed Martin joint venture, United Launch Alliance.
Texas-based Firefly is trying to mass-produce its medium-sized rocket, while developing a larger launcher under a new partnership with Northrop Grumman (NYSE:NOC).
Fresh off celebrating its Alpha rocket’s orbital debut last October, Firefly tried to raise $300 million by year-end to become cash-flow positive. By mid-February, it had only raised $30 million according to regulatory filings, although Weber said since then the company had reached about 75% of target.
Firefly expects to hold another funding round in mid-2024, Weber said.
Relativity Space said last week it was ditching its centerpiece small rocket, Terran 1, for a larger planned rocket, Terran R, a decision roughly a year in the making as demand for small rockets faded, CEO Tim Ellis said in an interview. The Long beach, California company to date has raised $1.3 billion, compared to Firefly’s total $390 million which includes some funds from the ongoing fund-raising effort.
“It was a lot better to just put those resources into Terran R because that’s going to be a way-more-profitable way to allocate the team that we have,” Ellis said.
The bigger rocket’s planned debut in 2026 will leave the company without any missions for roughly three years, but Ellis said he is not worried about future funding and declined to say when the company would do another funding round.
Astra Space, which ditched its small Rocket 3.3 for a planned, larger Rocket 4 in the next few years, has struggled to bring its stock price above $1, facing delisting threats from Nasdaq. Astra declined to comment on its financial struggles.
Firefly and Astra have added other business lines to make up for lost revenue, while Relativity has said its 3D printers used in rocket construction will be eventually employed for other products.
Firefly, which was forced by U.S. officials in 2021 to sever its Ukrainian ties through Noosphere Ventures over national security concerns, counts a lunar lander named Blue Ghost as a “very profitable” line of revenue, Weber said.
“I know Firefly’s management is very proud and vocal about Blue Ghost, but let’s hope they can walk the walk without the Ukrainians,” Noosphere founder Max Polyakov told Reuters.
Despite the startups’ struggles, launch demand has soared after sanctions following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine cut off access to Russian rockets. Recent failures with Europe’s Arianespace’s Vega-C rocket have added to demand in the U.S., outstripping the number of available rockets.
Shared missions to space on SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rockets, a cheaper, so-called rideshare option for satellite companies that helped kill the business case for small rockets, have taken some of that demand, but much of it remains.
Private plans to deploy mega-constellations, vast swarms of satellites in low-Earth orbit, have also given launch startups hope for future demand.
“The industry is now behaving as a more rational, capitalistic industry,” Erich Fischer, a senior partner at Bain and Co who advises space companies, said. “It’s never behaved that way before, ever.”